Sugar Over Vinegar
It's a debate as to what is being judged more closely and harshly on the new season of "American Idol": the would-be idols, or the new judges. First impressions after Week One and last night: the contestants are still a mixed bag of talent and bozos. The new judges are a breath of fresh air. If this sounds like an indictment against the sour-pussed Simon Cowell, so be it. The new twosome, former Aerosmith front man Steven Tyler and singer/dancer/actress Jennifer Lopez, have shown the ability to render judgment without quarts of vinegar. It comes out in teaspoonfuls from Tyler and Lopez. The third judge, Randy Jackson, seems to be at times trying to compensate for the loss of Cowell by going overboard with mean-spirited comments---even when they're obviously undeserved. They fall flat coming out of Jackson's mouth. But the trio of judges makes for a nice blend. Tyler is funny, Lopez is adorable and has empathy, and Jackson is the returning vet who feels the need to...